Joseph Story, Associate Justice of the Supreme Court, on the Massachusetts circuit instructs the Jury in united States v. Battiste:
It is that in criminal cases, and especially in capital [death penalty] cases the [J]ury are the judges of the law as well as the fact. … [T[hey must determine the law as well as the fact. In each they have the physical power to disregard the law, as laid down by the court.
[added 8/30/2026] >>>> NOTE <<<< The exact date for this event is not known. This approximate assignment was made for sorting purposes. If you determine the correct date and notify Tom Caldwell at tacaldwelljr@yahoo.com—with a verifiable reference—you will get credit for clarifying history.
Subsequent Events:
11/18/1841
Authority:
Articles V and VII of Amendment
ccc-2point0.com/constitution-for-the-united-states
References:
United States v. Battiste, 24 Federal Cases 1042, 1043 (D. Mass. 1835).